An analysis of the poem the nymphs reply to the shepherd
He questioned everything, including the religious and political ideas of his time and the premises of the courtly love tradition.
Together, these poems give readers a brief but thorough tour of all that is best and worst of the pastoral tradition in poetry.
Lies The nymph in this poem briefly mentions the possibility of the shepherd being untrue, in the second line, but for the most part she examines his offer to her as if he is being sincere. And while Marlowe presents nature as a place for seduction and pleasure, Raleigh depicts the grim fact of decay.
The nymphs reply to the shepherd translation
In her response, Raleigh has the nymph list reasons why the ideal life that the shepherd describes is unlikely to happen. Each person should be able to understand and agree with each of these views, although, deep down, each person probably leans toward one more than the other. Throughout the rest of the poem, she explains reasons why, whether he is sincere or not, she has to be skeptical that their life together would be as the shepherd describes it. In the beginning, there was still reasoning, for there was free will; free will will encompass reasoning because of the brain's natural ability to put value on right and wrong. Nature is ruler. It helps show that even though all odds seem against certain something, there can still be a glimpse of hope left in the mind. The ideal cannot exist without the contradiction of that ideal, and herein lay the strength of this companion poem. With these two poems, Raleigh and Marlowe created a sort of personality test that helps people understand their own basic beliefs. Source Motif 1: Mortality and Materialism The first is the thematic approach of the entire poem itself. Most helpful essay resource ever! You know how looking at a math problem similar to the one you're stuck on can help you get unstuck? Other writers have merged satire and parody with similarly impressive results. But could youth last, and love still breed, Had joys no date, nor age no need, Then these delights my mind might move To live with thee, and be thy love. Giving a materialistic gift to the nymph would be folly.
It seems she is rather looking for something timeless and ageless, but the shepherd is merely offering the worldly things which are perishable and transient. She states that neither her world, nor the world of the shepherd stays the same, and she determines that everything grows with age, just as love will grow and eventually die with the mortality of the human body.
But as it is not so, she puts her opinions to reply him in the ground of reality.
The shepherd emphasizes his love, as if love alone can conquer any problems, and he lists the things that he is willing to do for her as well as the splendors of the simple country life.
Nicholl, a travel writer and English literature scholar, traces the trip step-by-step. Philomel was lucky to sing her torture through her song as she became Nightingale.
The passionate shepherd to his love and the nymphs reply to the shepherd
The beloved will transform into wife and love will change into duty and responsibility. But the Nymph will not get any chance to share her sufferings. Instead, the secret is in the subject matter that these two poems cover so thoroughly. Brooke, C. It is this romanticized notion of life as a gentleman and courtier that Raleigh deems unrealistic in the face of changing times. John Bodenham. The shepherd that Marlowe presented sprang directly from the tradition of the ancient Greeks, with shallow rivers and singing birds presenting a perfect setting for the noble, optimistic lover who was a popular figure at the time. Elizabeth was the last of the Tudor dynasty , which ruled England from to The words forgotten and rotten, which are taken from the end of the fifteenth and sixteenth lines, help focus the imagery in the poem. Mega Essays LLC. The essays in our library are intended to serve as content examples to inspire you as you write your own essay. These might seem like odd reasons to turn down a potential love interest, but here is where being familiar with Marlowe's poem is really useful: each stanza in Ralegh's verse dismantles, dismisses, or qualifies a promise made in the corresponding stanza of Marlowe's original. Through a better understanding of mortality, reasoning, love, and time, the nymph sets out to help the shepherd comprehend the foundation of her rejection, why a life together would not work. And nope, we don't source our examples from our editing service!
Her personal relationships with suitors like Raleigh are kept out of the public eye. The beloved will transform into wife and love will change into duty and responsibility. But could youth last, and love still breed, Had joys no date, nor age no need, Then these delights my mind might move To live with thee, and be thy love.
An analysis of the poem the nymphs reply to the shepherd
The post-modern, ironic sensibility gives readers more than the surface situation that is presented, often giving the narrator a hidden, secret idea as well. Yagmin, James. John Bodenham. To protect the anonymity of contributors, we've removed their names and personal information from the essays. It helps show that even though all odds seem against certain something, there can still be a glimpse of hope left in the mind. What hooks you? To readers who assume that the two could then go on with their lives separately, this might seem unimportant. Raleigh points toward a more complex and realistic understanding of life that is subject to darkness and the inevitable progression of time. She sees the end of the shepherd and the end of his gifts; as they age along with the world, they head towards a common place, always changing from young to old. Latham, Agnes, and Joyce Youings, eds. The fact that the nymph only mentions this possibility in passing indicates that she probably thinks he is not lying, or, if he is, he is lying to himself as much as to her. Sir Walter Raleigh Source Concluding Remarks In conclusion, the nymph engages the ambiguous snafu throughout each line of the poem and replies to the shepherd with a multitude of images that help get her statements across.
based on 67 review